Hudson Valley's Finest Jewelers Newburgh NY Jewelers | J.Caroll Jewelers | Hudson Valley Jewelers

J.Caroll Jewelers...Our Customers are our Priority

To specialize in custom jewelry we maintain very close relationships with outstanding artisans in New York City, and have done so for many years.  Because of this our ability to seamlessly craft high quality custom jewelry in a short time frame is remarkable.  Our Model Maker has been creating beautiful and technically crafted pieces for us for over 20 years.  The Master Jeweler we utilize has been creating and repairing wonderful jewelry for 40 plus years.  Our model maker, master jeweler, diamond setters, polishers, casters, and suppliers have all been handpicked for their expertise. Likewise our team of experts provides services for some of the finest jewelry manufacturers and retailers in the United States.

Service and Quality are of the most importance to us, both of which we have complete control over and refuse to jeopardize. We want to be your jeweler without question, in order to do so we must provide the highest quality jewelry at a competitive price. As potential costs are important to all buyers,  J.Caroll Jewelers urges you to compare prices online and at various retailers to make sure you receive the best value for your money. Purchasing jewelry should be memorable and we will do our best to provide you with a wonderful experience.

Not only does J.Caroll Jewelers provide the best quality and value possible, we have a fine selection of in stock jewelry, an extensive library of jewelry catalogs to order most of which can be delivered the very next day, and the ability to create virtually any custom design imaginable. We have a full line of engagement rings, wedding bands, earrings, sterling silver jewelry, neclaces, pendants, bracelets and more. We specialize in custom jewelry, from a simple picture or sketch of your creation we can create a wax model followed by a finished piece of jewelry; if you can imagine it we can create it.

Please note that all diamond reports are not equal. Some labs have more stringent grading criteria and within their reports there are nuances that go beyond the four C’s (Carat, Color, Cut, and Clarity). At J.Caroll Jewelers we will point out these subtle differences that affect cost and beauty, so that you, the consumer, will be able to make a more educated decision.

We want to be your Hudson Valley Jewelers

 Jim O'Koon  was born and raised in Newburgh, N.Y.

Newburgh, NY is the town which Jim still resides and operates J.Caroll Jewelers.



  • B.A. from The University of Virginia
  • Multiple Certificates from The Gemological Institute of America
    • Diamonds
    • Colored Stones
    • Diamond Appraisals



In the Jewelry Industry since 1971

Opened and operated our retail business J.Caroll Jewelers since 1986